qedbot

Erdős·erdos:654

Erdős Problem 654

conjecture formal record: mixed source: open F2 declared

Machine-checked by Palomar.

Fidelity F2: The correspondence is declared through a Comparator challenge, an alignment table and written divergences.

geometry, distances·Source

AI activity

How grades work
Aletheia

1 Feb 2026

Partial result

partial A3 V1
Reasoning and sources

Autonomy

AI standalone; human involvement recorded as non-significant

F2 declared. The correspondence is declared through a Comparator challenge, an alignment table and written divergences.

declares divergences from its source reviewed by its authors only

Checks

3
  • verified·Palomar

    Registered by Palomar at 3146ec1b: Comparator confirmed 2 theorems prove the recorded statement within Palomar's axiom policy, replayed through Lean's kernel and the independent nanoda kernel

    project registered at a pinned commit·2026-11-03·commit 3146ec1b4c12

    PALOMAR-2026-11-03-000009

  • verified·Palomar

    Registered by Palomar at 3146ec1b: Comparator confirmed 1 theorems prove the recorded statement within Palomar's axiom policy, replayed through Lean's kernel and the independent nanoda kernel

    project registered at a pinned commit·2026-11-03·commit 3146ec1b4c12

    PALOMAR-2026-11-03-000006

  • verified·Palomar

    Registered by Palomar at fd7a8dc3: Comparator confirmed 2 theorems prove the recorded statement within Palomar's axiom policy, replayed through Lean's kernel and the independent nanoda kernel

    project registered at a pinned commit·2026-11-02·commit fd7a8dc3cf52

    PALOMAR-2026-11-02-000006

Declared by the projects

2

As each project's formalization.yaml states it.

Erdős Problem 654: the Aletheia counterexampleukniusanqian-alt/erdos654-lean · joined by anchor · Palomar

Read formalization.yaml

authors
ukniusanqian-alt
method
agent — Claude Fable 5.1 (claude-fable-5-1)
review
self-assessed (none)
sorry
0 unproved goals declared
sources
Semi-Autonomous Mathematics Discovery with Gemini: A Case Study on the Erdős Problems — formalizes, authors not-contacted; Erdős Problem #654 — background, authors n/a
divergences
The point set uses exponents 1..m instead of the paper's 10..m+9; the theorem statements are identical to those in google-deepmind/formal-conjectures.
checked by
Palomar
Erdős Problem 654: distinct distances from a point when no four points are concyclicveljjanoski/erdos654-palomar · joined by anchor · Palomar

Read formalization.yaml

authors
Daniel Veljjanoski
method
agent — Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic)
review
self-assessed (none)
axioms
Classical.choice, Quot.sound, propext
sorry
0 unproved goals declared
sources
Some of my favourite unsolved problems — formalizes, authors n/a; Semi-Autonomous Mathematics Discovery with Gemini: A Case Study on the Erdős Problems — adapts, authors not-contacted; Erdős Problem 654 — background, authors n/a
divergences
None known. The statements and definitions are verbatim copies of the formal-conjectures ones. "No four points on a circle" is formal-conjectures' NoFourConcyclic: no four distinct points of the set are cospherical, so collinear points are allowed, as in the question.
checked by
Palomar

Follow and discuss

All discussion

Discussion and bounties for this problem load here.

Something wrong or missing here? Request a correction or add a claim, with its sources.

Formal material

Formal statements · 1
Cited proofs · 1

Recorded elsewhere

Compare the registries
  • palomar — Erdős Problem 654: the Aletheia counterexample

    checked·their labels: registered

  • palomar — Erdős Problem 654: distinct distances from a point when no four points are concyclic

    checked·their labels: registered

  • vibemathed — Erdős Problem #654

    reviewed·machine-led·their labels: expert-verified, ai-discovered

Also known as · 3
  • https://www.erdosproblems.com/654
  • https://github.com/google-deepmind/formal-conjectures/blob/main/FormalConjectures/ErdosProblems/654.lean
  • FormalConjectures/ErdosProblems/654.lean

Cite this record

qed.bot, “Erdős Problem 654”, https://qed.bot/s/erdos-654, as of 20 Nov 2026.

This record as plain text, with each claim, its grades and its sources.